Young Girl by Gary Puckett & the Union Gap.
When Ern and I were jolting down some road to camp at some fishing hole - that had to be kept secret from the world lest even one other person stumble across it and it become "stuffed" - I'd dread this song coming up on whatever country collection tape we were listening to. I never had to beg him to fast forward it. I think he thought it was creepy too. Not good daddy-daughter sing-along material.
But at least the video provides some much-needed comic relief.